The Real Death Tax (Reprinted from 2006)

We’ve talked in the past week about the quality and costs of care in the United States. Our patent (government sanctioned monopoly) system is part of the problem.

Big PHARMA maintains that it is essential to have exclusive patents now up to 20-25 years in length to assure profits that will allow continued research and development of new drugs. As a result of Pharma’s effective congressional lobby, pharmaceuticals are the only uncontrolled, i.e. not open to negotiation and price setting, of the health care expense areas. Hospitalization, doctor’s fees, laboratory costs are all negotiable and discounted by the various health care payers. As a result, the rate of increase of spending on pharmaceuticals far exceeds that of other areas–13% a year since 1980. More on health care costs here and here.

Patent law has been carefully crafted to maximize profits of the drug industry. During the patent protected period drug companies can and do charge whatever they wish for a product. As a result, over the past 30 years drug prices have risen exponentially to unimagined levels and the industry has enjoyed record profitability “one example is that in 2002, the combined profits for the ten drug companies in the Fortune 500 ($35.9 billion) were more than the profits for all the other 490 businesses put together ($33.7 billion).”

When I started my medical oncology practice in the 70′s the cost of anticancer drugs averaged under $100/month. By the 90′s the pricing of new drugs broached the $1000/month, and by 2005 we were in the area of $10,000/month for some new drugs. For more look here.

It’s an unfortunate fact that in cancer therapy pharmaceutical costs have become what is essentially a death tax on the desperately ill. Your give your money or your life is on the line. Consider the number of people each year facing a life threatening illness. Consider also that the cost of many of these new drugs/year exceeds the average and median incomes in the U.S.; exceeds the cost of new automobiles; and over the lifetime of a patient the cost of a single medication can exceed the cost of the home of most americans. (see previous post on imitinib) Instead of a benevolent health care system in which access to care and restoration of health are the goals, we have a system whose main purpose is to maintain the profits of the health care industrial complex. The result is wealth redistribution rather than a fair price.

Pricing of pharmaceuticals is not sustainable and is the equivalent of a market bubble that cries out for correction.

Medicynic:  This post is reprinted from 2006.  The Ryan plan is the same idea.  It formalizes a tax on whatever wealth you may have  from those with limited resources to the one of the wealthiest industries.  It’s rationing of care by wealth–the new American way? 


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s